Smile is cheap to start. Expensive to stay.
Most small and medium stores pick Smile (Smile.io) for its free plan, and it's a fair choice on day one. It covers points on orders, simple discount rewards and a referral program. For the first few weeks it feels like a bargain.
Then you want to implement a more serious loyalty program. You want points to expire so your liability doesn't grow forever. You want a Gold tier for your best customers. You want customers to see their balance when they log in. Each of those is a $199/month feature on Smile. By then you have hundreds of members with balances, and moving apps feels like a project. That is the lock-in, and it is the most common complaint in Smile's own reviews.

As of October 21, 2026, 33 features in the Smile admin aren't available on the free plan. Here is what each plan unlocks.
“Beware of the bait and switch for pricing and features that should be included but behind paywalls. You'll be paying $200/month shortly.”
Smile merchant review, May 2025, 1★“Pushing you to upgrade to higher plans for easier to use features.”
Smile merchant review, February 2026, 1★That's why merchants with small and medium stores looking for a Smile.io alternative end up comparing price ladders, not feature lists. Froonze works the other way round: if a feature isn't listed against a paid plan on our pricing page, it's on the free plan. There are no hidden switches in the admin and no upgrade walls you only find by clicking around.
A predictable bill, even in your best month
A sales spike shouldn't punish you or your customers. Froonze never charges overage fees, so your price only changes when you decide to upgrade. And going over your plan's order limit never affects your customers. Only the admin locks until you upgrade or the cycle resets.
Smile, over the limit
- Month 1
- Smile notifies you and gives you the rest of the month to review plans. The program keeps working.
- After that
- You have to upgrade to keep the program running.
- Overage fees
- Growth: $20 per 100 orders above 2,500. Plus: $5 per 100 above 7,500. Essential and Standard have hard caps, so you have to move up a plan.
- Applies to
- Every plan with an order limit.
Froonze, over the limit
- Customers
- See every widget, earn and redeem points, apply coupons, receive emails. Nothing looks different.
- You
- The admin locks until you upgrade or your billing cycle resets.
- Overage fees
- None, on any plan. Unlimited ($60) has no order cap at all.
- Applies to
- Every plan, free included.
Example: a holiday month that doubles your orders
A store usually does 2,000 orders a month. In November it does 4,000.
- A normal month: $199, within the 2,500-order allowance.
- November: 1,500 extra orders × $20 per 100 = $300 in overage fees.
- Your loyalty bill is 2.5× higher in the month you're busiest.
- A normal month: $60.
- November: still $60. No order cap, no overage fees.
- You know your bill before the month starts.
What typical stores pay each month
At every size we checked, Froonze costs less. The gap is widest for stores that want VIP tiers, store credit or API access.
Froonze: Loyalty Free $0 + Reviews Basic $5
Froonze: Loyalty Free $0 + Reviews Basic $5
Froonze: Loyalty Advanced $10 + Reviews $10
Froonze: Loyalty Unlimited $60 + Reviews $50
Froonze: Loyalty Unlimited $60
Bars drawn to scale within each card. Smile figures use Smile list prices, plus Judge.me Awesome ($15/month) where the store wants reviews, since Smile has no reviews of its own.
Smile can't reward reviews on its own
Smile is a loyalty app only. To give customers points for reviews you need a second reviews app, paid plans in both, and an integration between two companies. On Froonze it's one app and $5 a month.
- Smile Essential, $15: every integration is locked on Smile's free plan.
- Judge.me Awesome, $15: Judge.me's integrations need its paid plan.
- Two dashboards, two bills, two support teams.
- The link between them belongs to neither company. When it breaks, each side points at the other.
- Froonze Loyalty Free, $0: includes the “points for reviews” earning rule.
- Froonze Reviews Basic, $5: photo and video reviews, up to 100 orders a month.
- One app and one dashboard. Reviews and points talk to each other natively, with nothing to connect.
- Already on Judge.me? Froonze Loyalty integrates with it too, from the $10 Advanced plan.
Every integration between two apps is one more thing that can break. It's not anyone's fault: two products ship updates on two schedules. One Smile reviewer describes an integration that stopped working without warning for about six months. When reviews and points live in the same product, there is no seam to come apart.
Four important features Smile charges more for
Store credit, emails from your own domain, loyalty on the account page and API access all cost more on Smile, or need a second app.
Store credit rewards: free on Froonze, $79 on Smile
More and more Shopify merchants reward customers with native Shopify store credit instead of discount codes. Froonze includes store credit rewards on the free Loyalty plan. Smile puts them on its $79/month Standard plan.
- Store credit reward: Standard plan.
- Not available on Free or Essential.
- Native Shopify store credit as a reward, on the free plan.
- Store-credit cashback on orders, also free.
Store credit is the reward that feels most like money. It sits in the customer's Shopify account and applies at checkout, with no code to copy or lose. That is why it's taking over from coupon codes in a lot of loyalty programs. Paying $79 a month just to offer it is hard to justify for a small store. Our guide explains how to reward loyalty with Shopify store credit.
Loyalty emails from your own domain
Customers trust emails that come from your store. Froonze sends loyalty emails from your own domain on every plan, the free one included. Smile's emails always come from Smile's domain. The only way to send them from yours is to route them through Klaviyo, which is another app to manage and pay for.
- Emails send from rewards@customer-mail.smile.io. You can change only the sender name and reply-to address.
- For your own domain: connect Klaviyo, which needs Smile Essential ($15/mo) for integrations, plus a Klaviyo account.
- Loyalty emails send from your store's own domain, on every plan.
- No extra app needed.
Put the loyalty program where customers look for it
Shoppers expect to find their points in “My account”, the way they do on most big stores. Froonze has a full customer account widget with the loyalty program built in. Smile only offers a points banner on the account page, on its $199 plan.
A points banner, on Growth
- Customer account points banner: $199/mo (Growth).
- Loyalty Hub page: $199/mo (Growth).
- No account page of its own. You keep Shopify's default one.
A full account page with loyalty inside
- Points balance, VIP tier, rewards and referral link on the customer's own account page.
- Wishlist, order history and profile in the same place.
- Optional: Loyalty works without it, through the floating widget and the New Customer Accounts widget (available on the free plan).
API access: $60 a month, not $999
If you want to connect your loyalty program to your own systems, such as a custom app, a data warehouse or a headless storefront, you need API access. Smile keeps its REST API on Smile Plus, at $999 a month billed annually. Froonze includes API access on Loyalty Unlimited, at $60 a month, billed monthly.
- REST API on Plus only.
- Billed annually: $11,988 up front for a year.
- Not available on Free, Essential, Standard or Growth.
- API access included.
- Billed monthly, cancel any time.
- Also includes Apple and Google Wallet cards and checkout redemption.
Support is where reviews are won and lost
Froonze has a perfect 5.0 rating on the Shopify App Store, and merchants mention our support more than anything else. In Smile's critical reviews, support is the complaint that has grown the fastest.
Froonze rating on the Shopify App Store, across 270+ reviews.
Smile reviews rated 1–4★ that complain about slow or unhelpful support, out of 381 with text.
of those 51 support complaints were written in 2023–2026, more than the previous nine years combined.
The pattern in Smile's 1–4★ reviews is consistent: replies that take days, no weekend coverage, template answers and no hands-on help with setup. Every Froonze support person can fix technical problems, so there is no first-line queue before you reach someone who can help. We'll help you style the widgets to match your theme, too.
Which plan unlocks each feature
The two apps do most of the same things. The difference is the price of the plan you need.
Monthly prices in USD. Smile data checked October 21, 2026.
| Feature | Smile | Froonze | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plans | |||
| Paid plans | $15 · $79 · $199 · $999Order caps: 500 · 1,000 · 2,500 · 7,500 a month (Free: 200). Plus is billed annually. Overage fees per extra 100 orders on Growth and Plus. | $10 · $30 · $60Order caps: 500 · 1,000 · none (Free: 100). No overage fees on any plan. | Froonze |
| Over the order limit | Upgrade to keep the program running | Program keeps running; admin locks | Froonze |
| Program | |||
| VIP tiers | Growth $199 | Advanced $10Up to 5 tiers. Entry by spend, order count or points. Status can last forever or reset monthly, quarterly or yearly. Points multiplier per tier. | Froonze |
| Points expiry | Growth $199 | Advanced $10With up to 2 reminder emails | Froonze |
| Store credit rewards | Standard $79 | FreeNative Shopify store credit | Froonze |
| Gift card rewards | Standard $79 | Not offered | Smile |
| Subscription rewards | Standard $79 | FreeThrough spending rules that apply to subscription orders | Froonze |
| Referral program | Free | Advanced $10 | Smile |
| Bonus points campaigns | Standard $79 | Through Shopify Flow, from Advanced $10 | Depends |
| On your store | |||
| Loyalty in the customer account | Points banner, Growth $199 | Full account widget, Accounts plugin from $5 | Froonze |
| Loyalty landing page | Essential $15 | Advanced $10 | Froonze |
| Product reviews | Not offeredNeeds a separate app | Reviews plugin from $5 | Froonze |
| Points for reviews | Essential $15 + a paid reviews app | Free with Froonze Reviews | Froonze |
| Emails from your own domain | Only through KlaviyoOtherwise sent from rewards@customer-mail.smile.io | Free, every plan | Froonze |
| Languages | Up to 25 | Virtually any language Shopify supportsDashboard and customer-facing widgets | Froonze |
| In-store and integrations | |||
| Shopify POS | Free | Advanced $10 | Smile |
| Apple and Google Wallet cards | Not offered | Unlimited $60Staff scan the card's QR code in Shopify POS | Froonze |
| Integrations | Essential $15Pricing page caps it at 1 on Essential, 2 on Standard | All from Advanced $10Klaviyo, Judge.me, PushOwl, Shopify Flow and more | Froonze |
| Checkout redemption (Shopify Plus) | Growth $199 | Unlimited $60 | Froonze |
| API | Plus $999, billed annually | Unlimited $60 | Froonze |
| Reporting | |||
| Analytics | 10 data exports free; 6 dashboards and 26 reports from $15 to $999 | Loyalty engagement analytics on every plan, free included | Depends |
When Smile is the better choice
Smile is a mature, well-known app with about 4,640 reviews. It's the better pick in a few specific cases.
Pick Smile if you
- Need referrals or POS earning at $0. Both are on Smile's free plan. Froonze includes them from $10.
- Want gift card rewards or built-in bonus campaigns, and are fine paying $79 a month for them.
- Need deep reporting such as benchmarks against other stores, and can budget $199 a month.
Pick Froonze if you
- Want VIP tiers or points expiry without a $199 plan.
- Want native Shopify store credit rewards on the free plan, not a $79 one.
- Need API access for $60 a month instead of $999 billed annually.
- Want product reviews and points for reviews in the same app.
- Want loyalty emails from your own domain without a second app.
- Want a predictable bill that tops out at $60 for loyalty, with no overage fees.
- Care about fast, technical support from a team that sets things up for you.
Moving from Smile? We'll do it with you, free
Free migration help is open to every Froonze merchant, on every plan, the free one included. Your customers keep their points balances.
Download your customer list with points balances as a CSV. Smile's export is free on every plan.
Our team imports the balances and helps you recreate tiers, earning rules and rewards.
Check a few balances, VIP statuses, reward emails, referral links and POS before you switch.
Remove Smile's theme blocks and uninstall once everything matches.