We make Froonze, which is one of the apps on this list.
Smile.io is the loyalty app most Shopify stores try first, and its free plan is a good start: points, referrals and Shopify POS for up to 200 orders a month. The trouble starts when the program grows. VIP tiers and points that expire both need Growth at $199 a month. Rewards paid as store credit need Standard at $79. And the free, Essential and Standard plans stop at their order limit, so a busy month means a bigger plan.
Merchants say this in their reviews too. One wrote that "you'll be paying $200/month shortly". Another found that after moving to a smaller plan, customers could still see their points but couldn't redeem them at checkout. A third said that once you upgrade, "you will be forced to pay $199/mo FOREVER or Cancel".
We split the alternatives into three groups: apps that cost less than Smile for VIP tiers, points expiry or store credit, apps that put loyalty and product reviews in one place, and two well-known apps that cost more. For each one, we show what it costs, who it's best for, and what merchants complain about in their 1 to 3 star reviews. Prices come from each app's pricing page and App Store listing, checked November 2 and 3, 2026, and we read every 1 to 3 star review each app got since May 2025. If you're comparing every loyalty app, not just Smile alternatives, see the 10 best Shopify loyalty apps.
What Smile.io charges for each feature
| Feature | Smile.io plan | Price per month |
|---|---|---|
| Points, referrals, Shopify POS | Free | $0 |
| Store credit rewards | Standard | $79 |
| VIP tiers | Growth | $199 |
| Points expiry | Growth | $199 |
| Points balance on the customer account page | Growth | $199 |
| Orders over 2,500 | Growth | $20 per 100 orders |
| Loyalty emails from your own domain | Not offered | Sent from Smile's domain; your domain only through Klaviyo (Essential, $15) |
| API access | Plus | $999, billed annually |
From Smile.io's pricing page, checked November 2, 2026. Order limits: Free 200 a month, Essential 500, Standard 1,000, Growth 2,500. Every plan in detail: Smile.io pricing.
Smile.io alternatives compared
Each feature column shows the cheapest plan that includes it, per month.
| App | VIP tiers | Points expiry | Store credit rewards | Referrals | Shopify POS | Points on the customer account page | Product reviews | Emails from your domain | API | Free plan | App Store rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Smile.io (for reference) | $199 | $199 | $79 | Free | Free | $199 | Separate app | Not offered | $999 (annual) | 200 orders/mo | 4.9 (4,657) |
| Froonze | $10 | $10 | Free | $10 | $10 | Free | Same app, from $5 | Free | $60 | 100 orders/mo | 5.0 (275) |
| Appstle | $30 | $30 | Free | Free | $10 | Not listed | Separate app | Free | On request | 250 orders/mo | 5.0 (1,465) |
| Rivo | $49 | $49 | Set up by Rivo | $49 | $15 | Rivo Accounts, $499 | Separate app | $49 | $499 | 200 orders/mo | 4.7 (1,437) |
| Flits | $49 | $199 | $15 | $49 | $15 | Free | Separate app | Free | $199 or Enterprise ³ | 250 orders/mo | 5.0 (390) |
| Joy | $129 | $29 | Not listed by plan | Free | $129 | $129 | Separate app | $29 | $499 | 250 orders/mo | 4.9 (1,790) |
| BON | $129 | $15 | Not listed | Free | $29 | Not listed | Separate app | Not listed | Enterprise quote | 150 orders/mo | 5.0 (1,979) |
| Growave | $199 | $199 | $199 | $15 | $15 | $199 | Included | $199 | $499 | 200/mo, 500 in total | 4.8 (1,292) |
| Okendo | $99 | $99 | $99 | Separate product | $99 | Not listed | Same app, separate product | Add-on | $299 | Reviews only | 4.8 (1,446) |
| LoyaltyLion | Add-on on $199 | $199 | Not listed | $199 | $199 | $199 | Separate app | No, LoyaltyLion's domain | $199 | 400 orders/mo | 4.7 (547) |
| Yotpo | Quote | $199 | Not listed | Free | Free | Not listed | Separate Yotpo product | Not listed | Enterprise quote | Under 100 orders/mo | 4.7 (968) |
Prices from each app's pricing page or Shopify App Store listing, checked November 2 and 3, 2026. "Not listed" means the app's pricing page doesn't mention it. Okendo Loyalty includes every loyalty feature on every plan and is priced by order volume. ³ Flits' plan card puts its custom API on Established, while its comparison table says Enterprise. Flits' website lists Shopify POS on Established ($199), but in the app it unlocks on Starter ($15). LoyaltyLion's App Store listing includes VIP tiers in Classic, while its pricing page sells them as an add-on.
What a full program costs compared with Smile
VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and store credit rewards, at three store sizes:
| App | 200 orders/mo | 800 orders/mo | 2,000 orders/mo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Smile.io | $199 | $199 | $199 |
| Froonze | $10 | $30 | $60 |
| Appstle | $30 | $30 | $30 |
| Rivo | $49 | $129 | $369 |
| Okendo ² | $99 | $299 | $699 |
| Joy ¹ | $129 | $129 | $129 |
| BON ¹ | $129 | $129 | $129 |
| Flits | $199 | $199 | $199 |
| Growave | $199 | $199 | $274 |
| LoyaltyLion | $199 + VIP add-on | Quote | Quote |
| Yotpo | Quote | Quote | Quote |
Per month, checked November 2 and 3, 2026. ¹ BON's pricing doesn't list store credit rewards, and Joy's doesn't say which plan includes them. ² Okendo Loyalty only; referral campaigns are a separate Okendo product. Above 2,500 orders Smile adds $20 per 100 orders, while Froonze stays at $60.
Rivo gets more expensive than Smile above 1,100 orders a month, Okendo above 200, and Flits costs the same as Smile once you want points to expire. Above 1,000 orders and up to 2,000, Appstle costs less than Froonze ($30 vs $60).
Cheaper than Smile.io
1. Froonze: VIP tiers and points expiry from $10 (vs $199 on Smile.io)
Froonze is one app with separate plugins for loyalty, product reviews, wishlist and customer accounts, so you pay only for the ones you use. The loyalty plugin has VIP tiers, points expiry and store credit, the features most merchants upgrade Smile for, from $10 a month, and caps at $60 however many orders you get. On every plan, including Free, our team styles the widgets to match your theme and moves your Smile data over.
Plans: Free: 100 orders/mo · Advanced $10: 500 · Premium $30: 1,000 · Unlimited $60: no limit, no overage
- Cheaper than Smile: VIP tiers and points expiry at $10 instead of $199, store credit rewards and the points balance in the Shopify customer account on the free plan (Smile puts it on Growth at $199), fully customizable loyalty emails sent from your own domain on the free plan (Smile's always come from Smile's domain), API access at $60 instead of $999 billed annually, and no overage fees on any plan. Anything not named in a paid plan is on the free plan.
- Reviews in the same app: customers earn points for reviews on the free loyalty plan, and Froonze Reviews starts at $5. On Smile, the Judge.me integration needs Essential ($15), plus Judge.me's Awesome plan ($15) on its side.
- Worse than Smile: the free plan stops at 100 orders a month instead of 200, referrals need the $10 plan, and gift card rewards and built-in bonus campaigns aren't offered (both are on Smile's Standard plan at $79).
Best for: stores of any size that want VIP tiers, referrals and points expiry for $10 a month instead of $199 on Smile.io, and $60 at most with no overage fees.
Rating: 5.0 from 275 reviews, Built for Shopify, and no 1 to 3 star reviews in the last 18 months. See also Froonze vs Smile.
2. Appstle Loyalty: closest on price
Appstle's free plan covers 250 orders with referrals and store credit. VIP tiers and points expiry come with Business at $30 a month for up to 2,000 orders, which is the lowest price on this list above 1,000 orders and up to 2,000.
Plans: Free: 250 orders/mo · Starter $10: 500 (adds POS) · Business $30: 2,000 · Business Premium $100: 5,000, then $0.015/order
Best for: stores with 1,000 to 2,000 orders a month that can handle some setup themselves.
Rating: 5.0 from 1,465 reviews.
3. Rivo: cheaper VIP tiers for smaller stores
Rivo puts VIP tiers, referrals and points expiry on Scale from $49 a month, and Shopify POS on Essential at $15.
Plans: Free: 200 orders/mo · Essential $15: 500 · Scale from $49: 400, then $20 per 100 (capped at $499) · Plus $499: 2,500
Scale grows with your orders, so it costs more than Smile above 1,100 orders a month ($209 at 1,200). At 2,000 orders it's $369. Store credit rewards are set up by Rivo's team rather than switched on in the app.
Best for: stores up to 1,100 orders a month that want VIP tiers for less than Smile.
Rating: 4.7 from 1,437 reviews.
4. Flits: cheaper VIP tiers, same price for expiry
Flits puts store credit rewards and Shopify POS on Starter at $15, and VIP tiers and referrals on Growth at $49. It also sends emails from your own domain on the free plan.
Plans: Free: 250 orders/mo · Starter $15: 500 · Growth $49: 1,000, then $10 per 100 · Established $199: 4,000, then $10 per 100 · Enterprise: quote
Points expiry needs Established at $199, the same price as Smile. Full breakdown: Flits pricing.
Best for: stores that want VIP tiers and store credit but don't need points to expire.
Rating: 5.0 from 390 reviews.
5. Joy Loyalty: cheaper expiry, VIP at $129
Joy's free plan covers 250 orders with points and referrals. Points expiry comes with Essential at $29, while VIP tiers, Shopify POS and wallet passes need Advanced at $129.
Plans: Starter (free): 250 orders/mo · Essential $29: 500, then $15 per 100 · Advanced $129: 2,000, then $10 per 100 · Ultimate $499: 7,000, then $5 per 100
Best for: stores that want expiring points and store credit without VIP tiers.
Rating: 4.9 from 1,790 reviews.
6. BON Loyalty: cheap basics
BON has free referrals and puts points expiry, birthday rewards and Klaviyo on Starter at $15. Shopify POS needs Basic at $29.
Plans: Free: 150 orders/mo · Starter $15: 300 · Basic $29: 500 · Growth $129: unlimited
VIP tiers need Growth at $129, and its pricing page doesn't list store credit rewards.
Best for: small stores that want referrals and expiring points for $15.
Rating: 5.0 from 1,979 reviews.
Loyalty and product reviews in one app
Some merchants leave Smile because they want loyalty and reviews in one place: one dashboard, one support team, and points for reviews without connecting two apps. With Smile, that takes a separate reviews app and usually a paid plan on both. Froonze has reviews built in (above). Growave and Okendo are the other two options.
7. Growave: loyalty, reviews and wishlist in one subscription
Growave bundles loyalty, reviews and a wishlist into one plan, so you pay one bill for all three. Referrals, birthday points and Shopify POS are on Entry at $15.
Plans: Free: 200 orders/mo, 500 in total · Entry $15: 500, then $20 per 100 · Growth $199: 1,500, then $15 per 100 · Plus $499 · Unlimited $999
VIP tiers, points expiry and store credit rewards all need Growth at $199, the same as Smile, and you can't pay only for the loyalty part. The free plan stops after 500 orders in total, so it works more like a trial. Full breakdown: Growave pricing.
Best for: stores that will use loyalty, reviews and a wishlist together and are fine paying $199 for VIP tiers.
Rating: 4.8 from 1,292 reviews. See also Froonze vs Growave.
8. Okendo: reviews first, loyalty priced by orders
Okendo started as a reviews app and now sells loyalty, referrals, quizzes and surveys as separate products you can bundle. Okendo Loyalty includes every loyalty feature on every plan, including VIP tiers, points expiry, store credit and Shopify POS, and is priced by your order volume.
Plans: Loyalty: $99 up to 200 orders/mo · $299 up to 1,500 · $699 up to 3,500 · $999 up to 10,000 · no free loyalty plan
That makes it cheaper than Smile only up to 200 orders a month. Referral campaigns are a separate product, and the free plan covers reviews only.
Best for: larger brands already using Okendo Reviews that want loyalty from the same vendor.
Rating: 4.8 from 1,446 reviews.
Well-known Smile.io alternatives that cost more
9. LoyaltyLion
LoyaltyLion has the biggest free plan here at 400 orders a month. Classic at $199 adds integrations, Klaviyo flows built for you and Shopify POS, but VIP tiers are a paid add-on on top, and stores above 500 orders need a custom quote. Long-time customers report "20% price increase year over year for the 'custom plans'".
Best for: stores that can stay on the 400-order free plan.
10. Yotpo Loyalty
Yotpo's free plan is for stores under 100 orders a month, with referrals and Shopify POS included. Pro from $199 adds points expiry and charges per order above 500, and VIP tiers need Premium, which is quote-only. One merchant saw $199 for 800 orders on the App Store become $259 once installed.
Best for: brands already paying for Yotpo Reviews or SMS.
How to switch from Smile.io
- Export your customers' points from Smile. Customers should keep what they've earned.
- Check that the new app imports points balances and recalculates VIP tiers from past orders, so your best customers don't drop back to the first tier.
- Tell customers before the switch and remind them to spend unused rewards, since issued discount codes usually don't move.
- Test on a free development store first if you don't want to experiment on your live store: how to set up a Shopify development store.
Froonze's team does the move from Smile for free on every plan: you send Smile's CSV export, and points balances come over. Once you've picked an app, our guide to setting up a Shopify loyalty program walks you through the rest.



