We make Froonze, which is one of the apps on this list.
Picking a loyalty app looks easy at first. Almost every app has a free plan, a 4.7+ rating and the same feature list. The free plans even compete on how many orders they cover, anywhere from 100 to 400 a month, so the one with the biggest number looks like the best deal. The differences show up a few months later, when you want VIP tiers for your best customers, points that expire, or a program that works in your physical store. That's when one app costs $10 a month and another costs $199.
So the free plan's order limit is the wrong number to compare. A big free plan with the key features locked behind $79 to $199 plans costs you more once your program grows. Compare what you'll pay for the features you'll want six months from now.
We compared 10 popular Shopify loyalty apps on three things: what each feature really costs, what happens to the bill as your orders grow, and what merchants complain about in their 1 to 3 star reviews from the last 18 months. If you haven't planned your program yet, start with how to set up a loyalty program on Shopify.
Shopify loyalty apps compared
Each feature column shows the cheapest plan that includes it, per month.
| App | Free plan | VIP tiers | Referrals | Shopify POS | Points expiry | Store credit rewards | Branded emails from your domain | Overage fees | App Store rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Froonze | 100 orders/mo | $10 | $10 | Earning free, redeeming $10 | $10 | Free | Free | No, capped at $60 | 5.0 (275) |
| Appstle | 250 orders/mo | $30 | Free | $10 | $30 | Free | Free | Above 5,000 orders | 5.0 (1,465) |
| Smile.io | 200 orders/mo | $199 | Free | Free | $199 | $79 | Not listed | Yes, on Growth | 4.9 (4,655) |
| BON | 150 orders/mo | $129 | Free | $29 | $15 | Not listed | Not listed | No | 5.0 (1,976) |
| Joy | 250 orders/mo | $129 | Free | $129 | $29 | Free | $129 | Yes | 4.9 (1,789) |
| Rivo | 200 orders/mo | $49 | $49 | $15 | $49 | Set up by Rivo | $49 | Yes, on Scale | 4.7 (1,437) |
| Flits | 250 orders/mo | $49 | $49 | $15 | $199 | $15 | Free | Not listed | 5.0 (390) |
| Growave | 200/mo, 500 in total | $199 | $15 | $15 | $199 | $199 | $199 | Yes | 4.8 (1,290) |
| LoyaltyLion | 400 orders/mo | Add-on on $199 | Not listed | $199 | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed, sent from LoyaltyLion's domain | Custom plans | 4.7 (547) |
| Yotpo | Under 100 orders/mo | Quote | Free | Free | $199 | Not listed | Not listed | Yes, per order on Pro | 4.7 (968) |
Prices from each app's pricing page or Shopify App Store listing, checked November 2, 2026. "Not listed" means the app's pricing page doesn't mention it. Every plan in detail: Shopify loyalty app pricing.
What a full program costs as you grow
Most stores that stick with loyalty end up wanting the same four things: VIP tiers, referrals, points that expire, and rewards paid as store credit. Here's the cheapest plan with all four at three store sizes.
| App | 200 orders/mo | 800 orders/mo | 2,000 orders/mo |
|---|---|---|---|
| Froonze | $10 | $30 | $60 |
| Appstle | $30 | $30 | $30 |
| Rivo | $49 | $129 | $369 |
| Joy | $129 | $129 | $129 |
| BON ¹ | $129 | $129 | $129 |
| Smile.io | $199 | $199 | $199 |
| Flits | $199 | $199 | $199 |
| Growave | $199 | $199 | $274 |
| LoyaltyLion | $199 + VIP add-on | Quote | Quote |
| Yotpo | Quote | Quote | Quote |
Per month, checked November 2, 2026. ¹ BON doesn't list store credit rewards. Above 2,000 orders Appstle moves to $100 a month (5,000 orders, then $0.015 per order), while Froonze stays at $60.
Froonze is the cheapest under 500 orders a month and ties with Appstle at 500 to 1,000. Between 1,000 and 2,000 orders, Appstle's $30 Business plan beats Froonze's $60. Above 2,000 orders Froonze is cheaper again, and it never charges overage fees.
What merchants complain about
Ratings near 5.0 don't tell you much, because most reviews are written in the first weeks. So we read every 1 to 3 star review from May 2025 to October 2026 for all 10 apps, ours included: 88 reviews in total. Froonze and Flits had none. Four themes came up again and again. Many reviews complain about more than one thing, so the counts add up to more than 88:
- Support (42 reviews): slow replies, chats that end without a fix, "24/7" support that isn't there at night.
- Price and plan walls (38): features that look included but need a much bigger plan, and bills that jump after a busy month.
- Bugs (20): duplicate rewards, Flow triggers that stop, points that don't come back after a refund.
- Migration (12): points and history that don't carry over cleanly, and slow help while moving.
Each app below has a short "Watch out for" note based on these reviews.
The 10 best Shopify loyalty apps
Froonze Loyalty: most generous pricing
Froonze is one app with separate plugins for loyalty, product reviews, wishlist and customer accounts, so you pay only for the ones you switch on. The loyalty plugin covers points, store credit rewards, VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry and Shopify POS, and caps at $60 a month however many orders you get. On every plan, including Free, our team styles the widgets to match your theme and moves your data over from another app.
Plans: Free: 100 orders/mo · Advanced $10: 500 · Premium $30: 1,000 · Unlimited $60: no limit, no overage
- On the free plan: points, rewards paid in native Shopify store credit, birthday points, points on product pages, earning points in Shopify POS, automatic loyalty emails sent from your own domain in your own design, and translations. Anything not named in a paid plan is on the free plan.
- From $10: VIP tiers, referrals, points expiry, redeeming points in Shopify POS, Shopify Flow, Klaviyo and other integrations.
- At $60: Apple and Google Wallet loyalty cards that staff scan in Shopify POS, points at checkout for Shopify Plus stores, and API access.
- Reviews in the same app: Froonze Reviews from $5 a month. Customers earn points for reviews, with bonus points for photos and videos, and that works on the free loyalty plan. Connecting two separate apps usually costs more: Smile's Judge.me integration needs Essential ($15), and Judge.me's loyalty integrations need its Awesome plan ($15).

The automatic emails matter more than they look. Points earned, birthday, points about to expire and new VIP tier emails remind customers about your store between orders, and they don't read like marketing.
Rating: 5.0 from 275 reviews, Built for Shopify, and no 1 to 3 star reviews in the last 18 months. Merchants mostly mention setup help and support from real people.
Appstle Loyalty: closest on price
Appstle is the strongest price competitor on this list. Its free plan covers 250 orders with referrals and store credit, and VIP tiers and points expiry come with Business at $30 a month for up to 2,000 orders.
Plans: Free: 250 orders/mo · Starter $10: 500 (adds POS) · Business $30: 2,000 (VIP tiers, points expiry) · Business Premium $100: 5,000, then $0.015/order
It's a good fit if you're between 1,000 and 2,000 orders a month and want VIP tiers at the lowest price for that size.
Rating: 5.0 from 1,465 reviews.
Smile.io: free referrals and POS
Smile is the best-known loyalty app on Shopify, with more reviews than any other app here. Referrals and Shopify POS are free, which few apps match.
Plans: Free: 200 orders/mo · Essential $15: 500 · Standard $79: 1,000 · Growth $199: 2,500, then $20 per 100 · Plus $999 billed annually
The catch is the jump. Store credit rewards need Standard at $79, and VIP tiers and points expiry both need Growth at $199. Free, Essential and Standard stop at their order limit, so a busy month means moving up a plan. Full breakdown: Smile.io pricing.

Rating: 4.9 from 4,655 reviews. See also Froonze vs Smile.
BON Loyalty: cheap basics
BON keeps the basics cheap. Referrals are free, and points expiry, birthday rewards and Klaviyo come with Starter at $15.
Plans: Free: 150 orders/mo · Starter $15: 300 · Basic $29: 500 · Growth $129: unlimited
VIP tiers only come with Growth at $129, and its pricing page doesn't list store credit rewards. Shopify POS and multiple languages need Basic at $29.
Rating: 5.0 from 1,976 reviews.
Joy Loyalty
Joy has a 250-order free plan with free referrals and reward emails, and points expiry and 30+ integrations on Essential at $29.
Plans: Starter (free): 250 orders/mo · Essential $29: 500, then $15 per 100 · Advanced $129: 2,000, then $10 per 100 · Ultimate $499: 7,000, then $5 per 100
VIP tiers, Shopify POS and wallet passes all need Advanced at $129, and every paid plan charges per 100 orders over its limit.
Rating: 4.9 from 1,789 reviews.
Rivo
Rivo has a 200-order free plan and puts Shopify POS and two integrations on Essential at $15. VIP tiers, referrals and points expiry come with Scale from $49.
Plans: Free: 200 orders/mo · Essential $15: 500 · Scale from $49: 400, then $20 per 100 (capped at $499) · Plus $499: 2,500
Scale grows fast: a store with 2,000 orders a month pays $369. Store credit rewards are set up by Rivo's team rather than switched on in the app.
Rating: 4.7 from 1,437 reviews.
Flits
Flits has a 250-order free plan and puts store credit rewards, Shopify POS and integrations on Starter at $15. VIP tiers, referrals and birthday points need Growth at $49.
Plans: Free: 250 orders/mo · Starter $15: 500 · Growth $49: 1,000 · Established $199: 4,000 · Enterprise: quote
Flits also sends emails from your own domain on the free plan. The expensive step is points expiry, which needs Established at $199. Full breakdown: Flits pricing.

Rating: 5.0 from 390 reviews. See also Froonze vs Flits.
Growave
Growave bundles loyalty, reviews and a wishlist into one subscription. Referrals, birthday points, Shopify POS and one integration are on Entry at $15.
Plans: Free: 200 orders/mo, 500 in total · Entry $15: 500, then $20 per 100 · Growth $199: 1,500, then $15 per 100 · Plus $499 · Unlimited $999
VIP tiers, points expiry and store credit rewards all need Growth at $199. The free plan stops after 500 orders in total, so it works more like a trial. And because it's a bundle, you can't pay only for the loyalty part. Full breakdown: Growave pricing.

Rating: 4.8 from 1,290 reviews. See also Froonze vs Growave.
LoyaltyLion
LoyaltyLion's free plan is the largest here at 400 orders a month and covers points, discount rewards and 7 languages. Classic at $199 adds unlimited integrations, Klaviyo flows built for you and Shopify POS for one location.
Plans: Free: 400 orders/mo · Classic $199: 500 · Advanced: quote · Plus: quote
VIP tiers are a paid add-on on Classic, and stores above 500 orders need a custom quote.
Rating: 4.7 from 547 reviews.
Yotpo Loyalty
Yotpo's free plan is for stores under 100 orders a month, with referrals, Shopify POS, Klaviyo and reward emails included. It pairs well with Yotpo's own reviews and SMS products.
Plans: Free: under 100 orders/mo · Pro from $199: 500, then $0.05 to $0.20 per order · Premium: quote · Enterprise: quote
Points expiry starts on Pro, and VIP tiers need Premium, which is quote-only. Pro charges per order above 500, so 800 orders a month costs $259.
Rating: 4.7 from 968 reviews.
Switching loyalty apps without losing customers
Moving apps feels risky once customers are collecting points, and 12 of the critical reviews we read were about migration. Before you switch, ask the new app two things:
- Do points balances move over? Customers should keep what they've earned.
- Are VIP tiers recalculated from past orders? Your best customers shouldn't drop back to the first tier.
Froonze's team does the move for free on every plan: points balances come over and VIP tiers are recalculated from order history. Unused rewards don't move, so remind customers to spend them before you switch.
How to choose
- New store, under 100 orders a month: any free plan works. Pick the app you'd still be happy paying for at 500 orders, because switching later is the hard part.
- Growing store that wants VIP tiers: compare the plan with VIP tiers, not the starting price. It's $10 on Froonze, $30 on Appstle, $49 on Rivo and Flits, $129 on Joy and BON, and $199 on Smile.io and Growave.
- Store that wants to reward reviews: with separate apps you usually need a paid plan on both, about $30 a month for Smile.io and Judge.me, plus an integration that keeps them in sync. If that sync breaks, you talk to two support teams to find out whose side the problem is on. Froonze has reviews in the same app: points for reviews work on the free loyalty plan, and Froonze Reviews starts at $5.
- Store with a physical shop: check that customers can redeem in Shopify POS, not just earn. Smile.io and Yotpo include POS for free, and Froonze and Appstle from $10. Wallet cards staff can scan are on Froonze's $60 plan and Joy's $129 plan.
- Shopify Plus or high-volume store: check that points can be redeemed at checkout, that there's an API, and what the bill looks like at your busiest month. Froonze has all three on its $60 plan with no order limit. LoyaltyLion and Yotpo put VIP tiers on quote-only plans, so ask for the price at your volume in writing.



